Articles by Phil Segner Sr. Research Analyst & Co-Portfolio Manager
Earnings Momentum
The Up/Down Ratio sports a reading of 1.44. Continuing the pattern of the previous two quarters, an above average “one-month” figure has been followed up with a below average “two-month” reading.
Estimating the Downside - August 2017
Based on 1957-to-date valuation metrics, the S&P 500 potential downside to median levels is -25%. Secular bear markets, however, fall well below median levels; based on a decline to the 25th percentile of 1957-to-date distributions, the S&P 500 would have to fall 36% to 1,591 (not a prediction).
Additional Factors
The broken record of ‘easy market returns and no market volatility’ plays on. In the nine months since the election, we’ve had eight monthly S&P 500 gains, and a price return of +15.5%. Some large “old economy” stocks helped the Cap Weighted measure outperform in July. Thus far in 2017, the Cap Weighted measure has outpaced the Equal Weighted Average in six of the seven months.
Growth vs Value vs Cyclicals
After a brief siesta in June, Growth got back to dominating Value in July. Our Tech-heavy Royal Blue High P/E Tier is now up 18.4% YTD, and its median P/E just passed 31x.
Small Cap vs Mid Cap vs Large Cap
Small Caps are now selling at a 2% valuation discount to Large Caps. It should be noted that this is only the tenth Small Cap discount observation since 2005.
Earnings Momentum
For the first month of Q2 2017 earnings, the Up/Down Ratio sports an above average reading of 1.95. But, we’ve seen this movie before—the two previous quarters started with similar results, only to end poorly.
Inflation Slip Sliding Away
Temporary and transitory? The CPI numbers have come in below estimates four months in a row.
S&P 500: That Makes Seven In A Row
The S&P 500 hasn’t seen a down quarter since the summer of 2015. Since then, a series of seven gradual quarterly gains have produced a 26% gain. As Big Tech had a rare misstep in June, large banks carried the load for another small monthly gain in the index.
Value Has A Moment In The Sun
Value led in all market cap segments during June, but for Q2 overall, Value was left in the dust. Continued momentum extended Growths’ YTD leads—especially in Small Caps.
Small And Large Are Even-Steven
The Small Cap P/E premium has been whittled away YTD, from 8% down to zero, as both tiers now sport a trailing P/E of 21.7x.
Earnings Momentum
The final Up/Down Ratio of Q1 shows a reading of 1.47. This is the highest figure we’ve seen in the past two years but it remains stubbornly below the long-term average of 1.50.
Estimating the Downside - July 2017
This multi-factor estimate of stock market risk is based on a regression to median stock market levels.
Earnings Momentum
The two-month Up/Down Ratio for Q1 results shows a reading of 1.48. Like the quarter before, an excellent “one-month” figure has been dragged down by a second month’s results.
Small Cap vs Mid Cap vs Large Cap
As the numerator of our numerator shrank, the Ratio of Ratios made its way into “Small Cap Discount” territory for the first time in seven months.
Growth vs Value vs Cyclicals
Value’s 2016 outperformance gap has been erased in the Large Cap space; Small Cap Value stocks slipped back into negative territory for YTD 2017.
Additional Factors
So much for that 2,400 resistance level. The S&P 500 plowed through its March 1st high as we closed out May and started June. Valuations, terrorist attacks, and a cloudier political climate are continually being shrugged off.
Estimating the Downside - June 2017
This multi-factor estimate of stock market risk is based on a regression to median stock market levels.
Additional Factors
Mr. Market bumped his head for the first time in quite awhile. After a streak of five consecutive months with new all-time closing highs, the S&P 500 failed to break through the March 1st highs during the month of April.
Growth vs Value vs Cyclicals
2017 is shaping up to be a Growth story. Our Royal Blue High P/E Tier is outperforming the Low Tier by a spread of 10% only four months into the year.
Small Cap vs Mid Cap vs Large Cap
We can say, with confidence, that although the relative P/E relationship sits at its long-term average (3% Small Cap premium), the absolute P/E ratios of both tiers are terribly high.